Facing a disciplinary investigation can be stressful. An investigator can ask relevant questions to establish what happened; there is no fixed list of questions HR is legally forbidden to ask. What matters is fairness, relevance and lawful handling of personal information.
Under the Acas Code, employers should investigate without unreasonable delay. An investigatory meeting should not itself result in disciplinary action. If there is then a disciplinary case to answer, the employer should give written details of the allegations and possible consequences, normally provide written evidence, allow reasonable time to prepare, and let you respond at the disciplinary hearing. You can ask for the purpose of an investigation meeting and a reasonable opportunity to check records; the Code does not guarantee advance disclosure of all evidence before an investigatory interview.
Questions about disability, health, family circumstances, religion, age or other protected characteristics may sometimes be relevant, for example to understand an adjustment request or the facts of an allegation. Unrelated intrusive questioning can be challenged; a question is not automatically unlawful simply because it touches on personal circumstances. Ask how it relates to the investigation and whether an adjustment is needed. Discrimination may be unlawful under the Equality Act 2010 in Great Britain; Northern Ireland has separate equality legislation.
Investigators must handle personal data lawfully, fairly and transparently under data protection law. There is no absolute ban on seeking relevant material from a personal phone or account, nor an automatic right to unrestricted access to it. Ask what information is needed, why, how it will be used and whether less intrusive evidence would suffice. Do not destroy relevant records. Seek advice before handing over private material if you are unsure.
If you are unsure of a question, say: 'Could you explain how this relates to the allegation?' If new matters arise, ask for time to consider them. If pressured to admit something, request a pause and make a careful, accurate response rather than guessing.
The statutory right to be accompanied by a fellow worker or eligible trade union companion applies at a disciplinary hearing that could result in formal action, and at certain appeals. Acas explicitly says there is no statutory right at an investigatory meeting, though workplace policy may allow one and adjustments may be appropriate. If an investigatory meeting becomes a disciplinary hearing, ask for its status to be clarified and for the appropriate procedure to be followed.
After a meeting, keep a factual note of questions, answers, people present and dates. If the process is unfair, check your employer's procedure, raise concerns in writing and seek independent advice promptly. Tribunal deadlines can be short.
Explore: https://myredundancyrights.co.uk/legality-checker · https://myredundancyrights.co.uk/my-rights · https://myredundancyrights.co.uk/action-plan
Official sources: Acas disciplinary and grievance Code (Great Britain); ICO monitoring workers and data protection; LRA discipline and grievances (Northern Ireland). This is general information, not advice on your particular case.