The First Offer Is Rarely the Best Offer
When an employer presents a settlement agreement, it is almost never their ceiling. It is their opening position. Settlement agreements are prepared by the employer's legal team with one objective — to resolve the situation at the lowest cost they believe you will accept. Understanding this is the first step to changing the outcome.
"I was offered £4,200," one MyRedundancyRights reader told us. "I pushed back on three points — the redundancy amount, the reference wording, and my notice period. I signed for £7,800 and a written reference agreed in advance. I had no idea any of that was negotiable until I read my rights."
That outcome is more achievable than most workers realise — and it starts with knowing what to ask for.
What Can You Actually Negotiate?
The statutory redundancy payment is the legal minimum — not the expected outcome. When pushing back on the amount, frame your request around one or more of the following:
Your length of service and the value you brought to the organisation Current market conditions and what it will cost you to find a comparable role Procedural flaws in how your redundancy was handled — inadequate consultation, questionable selection criteria, failure to consider alternatives. Procedural weaknesses give you significant leverage If the process was not followed correctly, your employer faces the risk of an Employment Tribunal claim. That risk has a value — and it is entirely reasonable to reflect that in your settlement figure.
Rather than working your notice period, you can negotiate to be paid in lieu of notice — a lump sum covering the notice you would have worked. This has two advantages: it puts money in your pocket immediately, and it frees you to begin your job search without the distraction or awkwardness of serving out your notice at your employer's premises.
Many employers prefer PILON arrangements too — it removes you from the building cleanly and quickly. Use that mutual interest to your advantage.
This is one of the most overlooked but most valuable elements of any settlement negotiation. A standard employer reference can be deliberately minimal — confirming only your dates of employment and job title. Without a negotiated reference, your former employer is free to say as little — or, in some cases, as much — as they choose.
Insist on an agreed reference, worded in your favour, attached as a schedule to the settlement agreement itself. Once it is in the contract, your employer is legally bound by it. This protects you from damaging or bare-bones references for years after the settlement is signed.
Ask to keep your laptop, phone, or other equipment you have been using. Older IT equipment has very little resale value to a company — it will likely be wiped and disposed of. To you, it has genuine practical value for your job search, retraining, or new role. Frame it as a practical request rather than a demand, and most employers will agree.
Ask your employer to fund a career coach, a CV writing service, or a professional outplacement programme. These services can cost several hundred pounds privately — but for an employer settling a redundancy, they are a relatively modest cost. Crucially, outplacement support is generally treated as tax-free — making it a cost-efficient benefit for both parties.
Key Facts Every Negotiator Should Know
The first £30,000 of a redundancy payment is currently free from income tax and National Insurance — negotiate to keep as much of your settlement within this threshold as possible Settlement agreements are legally binding only once you have received independent legal advice — your employer must contribute to the cost of that advice, typically between £250 and £500 Non-disparagement clauses should always be mutual — if you are agreeing not to speak negatively about your employer, ensure they make the same commitment about you Restrictive covenants — clauses preventing you from working for competitors — should be scrutinised carefully. Push to narrow their scope, duration, or geographical reach where possible You are not obliged to accept any settlement. If the offer does not reflect your situation, you have the right to take your case to an Employment Tribunal instead Statistics That Support Your Negotiation
Research consistently shows that workers who take independent legal advice before signing a settlement agreement achieve significantly better outcomes than those who sign without advice The majority of settlement agreements are reached through negotiation — employers rarely take the risk of tribunal proceedings when a reasonable settlement is within reach Procedural failures in redundancy processes are among the most common grounds for successful Employment Tribunal claims — and they remain powerful negotiating tools even when a claim is never filed Practical Steps — How to Negotiate Professionally
Do not respond immediately to any settlement offer — ask for time to consider it and take legal advice Identify every element that is negotiable before you make a counter-proposal Put your counter-proposal in writing — it creates a record and signals that you are informed and prepared Frame your requests professionally — reference market conditions, procedural concerns, and your contribution, not emotion Use a specialist employment solicitor — many offer fixed-fee settlement agreement reviews and know exactly where the room to negotiate lies Do not be pressured into signing quickly — a reasonable employer will allow you adequate time to take advice Take Action Today
👉 Read your full redundancy and settlement rights: https://myredundancyrights.co.uk/negotiate 👉 Use our free template letters to push back professionally on any settlement offer 👉 Find a specialist employment solicitor through our Partner Network 👉 Calculate what redundancy pay you are actually owed: myredundancyrights.co.uk 👉 Download our free Redundancy Action Plan — step by step from day one
MyRedundancyRights — free, plain English guidance for every UK worker. No jargon. No cost. No catch.